Clivus Multrum vs. Conventional Means of Waste Management

June 24th, 2020

Dear Readers,

If you have read the Our Waste Goes Where?! blog (and if you have, I applaud you..that was a rough one..) or are familiar with how wastewater treatment generally works, whether it be a septic tank or a treatment facility, you may be wondering how the Clivus Multrum composting toilet and greywater system is beneficially different. I know that I was certainly curious…I mean, the results are similar. Most of the solid and liquid waste, whether flushed or composted in a hole, eventually find their way back into the great world as either fertilizer or drainage. So, what makes the idea of not just specifically the Clivus Multrum system, but a composting toilet in general, so enticing? 

Since William and I are looking to build The Seed in a rural area, I am going to directly compare a composting toilet and greywater system to what is most often offered to fellow rural inhabitants…a septic tank.

Conventional Means vs. Composting Waste

Composting Toilet

A composting toilet is, for us, preferable to a septic tank for three main reasons. 

One: It makes the home, and encourages the inhabitants within it to be, holistically self-sustaining, or, our version of net-zero living. Utilizing a composting toilet allows the home to have a reduced reliance and impact on the physical site it is on. 

There is no digging a sand mound, or installing deep in the earth a septic tank. The solid waste that settles in the tank does not need to be pumped out by a big truck, and then subsequently dropped off at a public wastewater treatment facility.

Rather, the solid and liquid waste that the inhabitants generate rest in separate bins until they can be returned to the earth as stable soil fertilizer. The owner or resident (William and I!) can do this themselves with a simple and common tool…a shovel. 

A composting toilet also results in a reduction of the home’s overall water usage. If you opt for the standard composting toilet, then you use no water when contributing your waste to compost. None. Even if you choose the foam flush composting toilet, you only use 6 ounces of water per flush. If you are relying on a rainwater pillow for your water supply, this is a HUGE plus…as well as a beautiful help in achieving net-zero living. 

The greywater garden for the greywater filtration and distribution would be the only alteration required to the land…and that is because we would physically be planting a garden which would aid in filtration and dispersal. Yay, plants! 

Not only would a composting system aid the home in being holistically net-zero, but it would better enable the inhabitants to take account for their own waste. Before researching for the blog,Our Waste Goes Where?!, I honestly had no idea what happened to my processed nutrients. I figured it went to our septic tank, which I knew had to be pumped once every couple years…but I had no idea that it eventually went to a wastewater treatment facility, and what that process looked like. Someone else took care of it. All I had to do was sit on the toilet, do my thing, and flush. Done. The mess was no longer mine. Because William and I intend to raise children in this crazy idealistic home of ours, we see the composting toilet as a great life lesson for them…in William’s (and a lil’ of Shelby’s words), it will be “teaching our children to not expect other people to clean up their nasty sh…enanigans.”

Two: Utilizing a composting toilet will also allow us to benefit from our own poop (and urine!). Rather than going to a store to buy fertilizer, which we ourselves probably helped contribute to, we could use our own composted waste to fertilize our soil (local regulations depending).  

Three: A composting toilet and greywater system also allow for ease and efficiency when putting a prefabricated house on-site. As stated in reason ‘number one,’ unlike a typical septic system, a composting toilet requires less on-site work. The composting tanks (for both solid and liquid fertilizers) are typically designed within the home’s building envelope. Admittedly, our current drawings for The Seed do not take into account the space required by the composting systems…something to ponder. 

The main on-site work would be for the greywater system (which does instil some more pondering…). A greywater garden would have to be planted, as well as the greywater distribution system installed.

Greywater System

A greywater distribution system such as that offered by Clivus Multrum, in comparison to the liquid waste distribution system offered by a septic tank, only distributes greywater. Urine is not included, and therefore not wasted. Rather, the urine is treated by the solid waste within the inclined compost tank, removed, and then held in a separate tank for use as eventual liquid fertilizer. The greywater is filtered through a top layer of soil and plants before its eventual self-distribution to the great unknown. 

Potential Idea for a Prefab Greywater Garden? Maybe?

We admittedly do have one concern with the greywater system in how it does in ease and efficiency of placing a prefabricated home on-site. If we must plant a greywater garden for every home, that will add to the amount of overall time it takes to install the home. 

All of this is fertilizer for thought as we continue to research for and build our own little prototype and home…thank you for reading, and stay tuned for more ponderings!

Sincerely,

Shelby Aldrich

3 Comments

  1. I am going to have to read this post again, hopefully I will understand it better. It is late, and I am tired, so, I will read it during the day when I am more aware of things.

    Reply
  2. Based on your greywater production calculations, what size would the garden need to be and how differently does it work in the summer or winter? Also, as someone allergic to bees, I would ask you to consider placement of said plants. Too many people do things like mailbox planters or gardens that then attract bees (who get disturbed when people walk by or fetch/deliver mail).

    Reply
    • These are excellent questions! Thank you for the critical thinking! I actually do not have answers to any of these questions, but Shelby and I certainly should figure them out as we continue our design. When we find these answers, we shall share!

      Reply

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published.

© 2020 Sustaining Tree

© 2020 Sustaining Tree